Charmed Ones vs. Resident Evil

[Jill Monroe]

Prue , Piper, Phoebe and Paige vs. Zombies , Tyrant and Nemesis from Resident evil!

you have four powerfull witches with powers that include: Telekinesis, Astral Projection, Premonitions, Levitation, Teleorbing, Glamoring, Teleporting, Temporal Stasis, Molecular accleration.

Then you have a hoard of Zombies, a violent and agressive super soldier and its revamped protoype (Nemesis) which posseses a terrifying arsenal of weapones.

It would be the ultimate clash between magick and biotechnology.

the VARIABLE FACTOR: the book of shadows.

Would the sisters have their manor and homefield advantage? or would they arrive in Raccoon City with only their powers and secondary abilities?

let's explore ALL the possibilities shall we?

[Caroline Forbes]

The Sisters could definitely AVOID the baddies from RE BUT...my question would be how they would actually defeat them. Phoebe would be USELESS of course. She'd be a zombie within the first 5 minutes. Piper from later season when she could blow things up? As long as she didn't get too overwhelmed, she'd win out. Ditto Prue, and whether there was anything she could throw at them available. Paige would just orb of to Tahiti or something...lol...

[Black King]

I'm giving to the Zombie Horde only for the numbers. If they're facing off against everything in raccoon city unless there is a kill all zombie spell against an army of Lickers, Devil dogs, undead ravens, worms, Nemesis, and the normals all it takes is one lucky shoot or something to catch One off guard and they all topple like dominoes. I'm putting money on Paige lasting longer thans to her power to teleport and orb objects to and from.

2 Quick questions. All the sisters both Prue and Paige? If a sister gets it does she keep her powers as a zombie?

[Caroline Forbes]

Ooh good question...

[Jill Monroe]

LOL @ Vil's first response. In THIS case..i actually think Phoebe would be pretty useFULL...they have portrayed her to be VERY good in close quarter combat and if you factor in her levitation and premonitions with the martial arts, she would be pretty deft at fighting off the more agressive things that charge at them.

Prue wouldnt just be able to throw things AT them, she would be able to THROW THEM. she would be able to knock GROUPS of enemies back and if you factor in her "telekinetic bomb blast" (from "morality bites") she would annihilate a chunk of the zombies. and she has her astral projection and martial arts skills as well.

Piper would be perfect for long range strikes in the air against the ravens and insects not to mention stopping any zombie or dog that advances with her temporal stasis.

Paige would be able to pick apart zombies with her teleorbing and could use the same power to move objects that Prue might not be using with her TK. they'd each pick up each other's slack and of course there's always the fact that she could spirit them all away, the question is....WOULD they even consider retreat as an option?

NOT when Prue was leading them , we saw that time and again and if they were coming to save Darryl or someone from Raccoon City you can believe they wouldnt turn back easily.

Typical when the Charmed Ones were "turned into things' they usually lost their own native powers and took on the powers or abilities of whatever they were turned into. but would they use the same spell they used to cure Piper of HER virus to nullify the T Virus in one of their own if they were bitten? I think if Prue were there that would be the first thing she suggests.


you have all four sisters, going into Raccoon City (since thats what you guys seemed to go with) each armed with ALL of their individual powers and the book of shadows spells.

their greatest weakness is the NUMBERS they face, as BK said...but they each have powers that would help out immensely against certain threats.

id still like some more feedback on this from you all and anyone who has any thoughts and ideas.

you guys REALLY think Paige is most likely to be the "sole survivor"? I'd give it to Prue and Piper if anything. but maybe thats because im thinking in terms of power levels.

[Caroline Forbes]

LOL @ Vil's first response. In THIS case..i actually think Phoebe would be pretty useFULL...they have portrayed her to be VERY good in close quarter combat and if you factor in her levitation and premonitions with the martial arts, she would be pretty deft at fighting off the more agressive things that charge at them.

But see, that's why I think she'd be toast - she has to get CLOSE to fight them. Chomp chomp bite bite.

Prue wouldnt just be able to throw things AT them, she would be able to THROW THEM. she would be able to knock GROUPS of enemies back and if you factor in her "telekinetic bomb blast" (from "morality bites") she would annihilate a chunk of the zombies. and she has her astral projection and martial arts skills as well.

But throwing them together isn't going to kill them. They could hold them back, but eventually, numbers will overwhelm.

you guys REALLY think Paige is most likely to be the "sole survivor"? I'd give it to Prue and Piper if anything. but maybe thats because im thinking in terms of power levels.

I don't think she'd be the sole survivor, really. I would bet on Piper.

[Black King]

Typical when the Charmed Ones were "turned into things' they usually lost their own native powers and took on the powers or abilities of whatever they were turned into. but would they use the same spell they used to cure Piper of HER virus to nullify the T Virus in one of their own if they were bitten? I think if Prue were there that would be the first thing she suggests.



That spell won't work when they used it in the show the doll they used came alive and started spreading the virus she had to others. If that happens with the T-virus without them knowing the army of Zombies just going to get bigger.

Piper would be a good bet for sole sole surviver but the lickers in particular are lightning fast, travel in packs of 3-4, are nonbelievable stealthy, and are smart enough to acttack from multiple angles and Piper still needs her arms to channel her power shes dieing fast.

Prue can knock them back but as Vil said that wouldn't kill them and numbers over whelm.

Phoebe close quarters against devil dogs is suicidal and i don't think she can hover forever. at most she can she herself dieing before it happens.

Paige Numbers overwhelms she has the best power set for this but shes still going to die.

[Jill Monroe]

now that i think about it...in this case Phoebe reminds me of "Miracle" (wasnt that her name?) from House of the Dead. She'd fight well for a while but as Vil points out...once a zombie or dog gets ahold of her..its over.

i was thinking about Prue (who as many know is my favorite) and you're right, while her knocking them back or sending them flying wouldnt kill them (unless she sent their heads smashing into walls or something) if you want to get imaginative with it. she COULD use objects to do the job for her, TK'ing man hole covers to slice heads off (several at a time)

severing and sending power lines at them to electrocute ect. she's been show to be able to do intricate things with her TK and of course there's always her slamming cars , trees and other objects into them to CRUSH them.

they'd need a STRATEGY to get in and out of the city and unfortunately (for the sisters...not for me since i hate her LOL) Phoebe would be cannon fodder.

my next question is, which sister(s) would be best suited to fight:

Nemeis

and why?

which SINGLE sister would be best suited for the dogs and crows?

AND (thinking about "Morality Bites") which sister (or sister combo) with the '10 year power boost' would have enough power to wipe out the zombie army?

[Black King]

If its one on one Paige on both.
Since her power doesn't factor with weight like Prue's does she can just orb him into the sun and be done. If he tries to fire on her she can also orb out of the way. In close hes fast but at a distance he is way too slow even with his railgun.

Paige once again orb them all into the sun or even better the underworld.

[Foxfire]

I think the Charmed Ones would take their battle to Raccoon City due to fear of nearby neighbors or other catastrophic damage.

I personally feel the Charmed Ones would win the battle based on their powers, their experience, and overall what they have been through. You have Prue, the oldest and wisest of the group whose very proactive in her approach and a huge strategist of the sisters. Piper, whose probably the heart and soul of the whole bunch who is like the "glue" to the backbone. Phoebe is a wild card but she’s proven to come through in the end and she does possess an otherworldly knowledge based on her curiosity. I really don’t know much about Paige (I stopped watching the show after the Third Season). However, based on her powers she’s an asset to the fight.

I fully agree with Farrah’s argument and power strategy for the girls. I also agree that Prue would be the sole survivor followed by Piper. Prue’s take charge no non-sense approach would prove valuable in her survival. Or even Piper, the second oldest of the group with her powers.

I think our girl Prue could handle big-bad Nemesis based on her powers, being the oldest, being proactive, and the strongest.

I think Piper would be good for dogs and crows based on her long - range power attacks. All she has to do is freeze and blow up lol. Or freeze and Prue could tk them out a window. Or Piper could blow out the window and Prue could tk the shards of glass.

As for the 10 year power boost, Prue and Piper hands down! Oldest, strongest, and more pro-active.

[Oblivion]

Whether they have the home field advantage or not, the Charmed Ones would win hands down.

When factoring in the ten year power boost from Morality Bites, the fact that they'd be outnumbered doesn't matter at all, in my opinion. In the future we saw Piper freeze a whole hell of a lot of people (and birds she hadn't even intended to freeze, I believe) without even exerting her full strength. All she would have to do is freeze practically everything insight, and then all four of the sisters could pick off frozen zombies, lickers, etc. one by one. Same goes for Prue's power boost, one flick of a wrist and there goes dozens of zombies flying away.

Although I hate her, I do think Phoebe would be pretty useful in the fight. She may not have the best active powers to fend off zombies, but all throughout the show she was always portrayed to be the best spell caster, or at least the best spell righter (she was even the one who taught/told Prue how to cast her first spell, I think?) She's been known to think on her feet, as well, so I wouldn't be surprised if she whipped up some quick offensive spells right off the bat to help even the tide (similar to how the sisters did when they were faced with the Warlock from the future, who stole the book, eventually vanquished Phoebe and Paige, etc. - I forgot the actual episode name. They came up with a whole new set of offensive and defensive spells right then and there).

Prue and Piper would be the strongest fighters all around, I'd think. Prue's telekinesis would be able to keep zombies at a distance, and she'd be able to use her surroundings against them, like pretty much everyone else has said already, hah. Piper would obviously be able to freeze and blow up - but I wouldn't just restrict her powers to long range birds and things like that. If the battle field is Raccoon City, she'd be able to blow up cars, pieces of buildings, power lines, etc. as well. All in all everyone would be extremely effective in vanquishing any Resident Evil creature that they came in contact with. Paige's orbing would clearly help, not only if they were forced to retreat, but she'd be able to orb things to the Underworld, too, just like Black King said.

I'm not sure if you can pick an individual sister who'd be better suited to face off against Nemesis (or any other Resident Evil big bad), simply for the reason that all three of them (I'm counting Phoebe out because even with her spell casting or what not, pretty sure Nemesis would pound her skanky ass into the ground if she didn't have help from one of her sisters) would have very different ways of fighting. I see Piper freezing Nemesis - and then blowing him up, if that didn't work, she'd at least be able to blow up parts of him, and his weapons. Prue would just slam him around with her telekinesis, or take his guns from him and shoot him to death, hah. Her battle techniques are virtually endless simply because her power isn't restricted to one set use, she can use it to do a lot of different things. Paige would either orb him away, orb away, orb his weapons away, etc.

The question is whether or not the sisters would be fighting their way out of Raccoon City, or fighting through the city in search of innocents. That would play a huge role in how the sisters fought. If they were looking for innocents their main objective would be to find their innocent(s), and protect them. If no innocents were involved, they'd be able to unleash all of their power without fear of hurting anyone else.

Sooo yeah, either way. Charmed Ones would dominate.